Seleste reviews: A Clockwork Christmas by JK Coi, PG Forte, Stacy Gail, and Jenny Schwartz
December 11, 2011 in Reviews
E-Book: 479 pages- Publisher: Carina Press (December 5, 2011)
- Sold by: Amazon Digital Services
- Language: English
- ASIN: B005Z1C47Q
Changed forever after tragedy, a woman must draw strength from her husband’s love. A man learns that love isn’t always what you expect. A thief steals the heart of a vengeful professor. And an American inventor finds love Down Under. Enjoy Victorian Christmas with a clockwork twist in these four steampunk novellas.
Anthology includes:
Crime Wave in a Corset by Stacy Gail
This Winter Heart by PG Forte
Wanted: One Scoundrel by Jenny Schwartz
Far From Broken by JK Coi
I love steampunk, and I love novellas, so I couldn’t resist the opportunity to read A Clockwork Christmas. Just as a note, all of the titles are also available for purchase individually.
As a whole, the anthology was an enjoyable read with great writing and plenty of romance. My biggest beef was that for a Christmas anthology, I felt like Christmas was just the time the stories were set rather than having a real part to play in them. This was true in varying degrees through the different stories, but I wish one of them would have felt like it really needed to be a Christmas story (if that makes sense). Also, overall, I wanted more steampunkery and action to balance the romance, but that’s me personally.
As for each story individually…
Crime Wave in a Corset: I really enjoyed this one. I liked casting the heroine as the “villain”, and I felt Cornelia and Roderick’s attraction right off. Both of their experiments lent a very steampunk air to the story and all the trappings (so to speak) of the genre were there. Some people would see Cornelia as wishy-washy with her affections, but considering the situation, I completely bought into her developing love-hate with Roderick
This Winter Heart: I wanted to love this story more, but when I read steampunk, I want an air of action and adventure to it. This story lacked that. It had an automaton/human hybrid for a heroine, which was cool, but beyond that, it felt like a standard romance of a wrecked marriage and a secret baby. I liked Ophelia and Dario fine, but I just wanted more meat to the story, or more connection to the characters.
Wanted: One Scoundrel: I adored the idea of steampunk in Australia (and actually told Jenny Schwartz so on Twitter). The steampunk aspects were woven in well, but again, I wanted more action. I adored both Esme and Jed, so from a romance standpoint it was a win, as well as all the Australian history worked into the story, but the action that was built into the end felt a bit forced to me, so I didn’t get lost in that the way I wanted to.
Far From Broken: This was another story where the heroine is part mechanical. Still love that, and in this case, I believed the anger and animosity between Jasper and Callie. She had every reason to hate him, and it showed, but so did their complete affection for each other. There was more action here, but it was disrupted by the antagonist being (for me) obvious from early on.
If you prefer more romance than action in your steampunk, I think you could do far worse than A Clockwork Christmas. However, in the end, the balance between steampunk, action, Christmas, and romance just wasn’t as strong as I wanted it to be for the anthology as a whole.










